If the U.S. were my students, they'd flunk

The National Alliance on Mental Illness recently released a report card on America's health care system for adults with mental illness. Our grade: D.

At the Newhouse School of Public Communications, where I teach, this is a failing grade. We flunk when it comes to creating a support system for people with mental illness. We have no network of consistent services, no consistent access to mental health care, and no standardized system of licensing or treatment criteria.

We fail in other ways, too. We as a society fail to take seriously the ravages of mental illness. We step over those with mental illness both literally and figuratively. We turn our faces away. We perpetuate the shame and stigma of diseases like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and, yes, eating disorders.*

My students always want to know how they can raise their grades. I put the same question to all of you: How can we as a society raise our grades when it comes to mental illness?

Here's my two cents on the subject:
1. Offer incentives to those studying to be doctors and therapists. One reason we have such a staggering lack of good mental health providers is that in our current health-care system (or shall we say lack of health-care system) they can't earn as much as other docs. This is partly a function of how our disgraceful so-called health insurance system works. See 2.
2. Mental health parity is a good first step, but it's full of loopholes. Enact legislation that prevents health insurers from weaseling out of covering mental health issues. The track record is dismal, especially for eating disorders.
3. The first two items on the list would start us on the road toward lessing stigma around mental health issues. Shame on the health insurers for heaping more shame, and financial burden, on families struggling with these issues.
4. Talk, talk, and more talk. The more we talk about a subject, the less shameful it becomes. Social change takes time. Let's get started.

What are your ideas?





* I'm not a believer in classifying eating disorders as mental illnesses, but for now that's where they reside and so that's where we've got to live with them.

Fat--it's all in your head

At least according to this editorial in the American Journal of Psychiatry, exploring the question of whether to make obesity a brain disorder in DSM-V.

Of course, it's not really clear what exactly they mean by brain disorder. Anorexia and bulimia are listed in DSM-IV as brain disorders, sorta, and I have to say, I'm not sure what that means, either. Insurers still treat them as mental health issues rather than biologically based illnesses, and use that as a way to skive off covering them (at least in beknighted states like Wisconsin, which have no mental healthy parity laws).

It depends what the rationale is here, really. What we now know about eating disorders like anorexia is that some people are genetically and biologically predisposed to them, and that environment seems to play some kind of role in triggering those who are susceptible. Maybe that's true for obesity. That makes more sense to me than suggesting that all so-called obese people are compulsive eaters, which we know ain't true. Yo-yo dieting might be the environmental trigger, resetting the metabolism over time in ways that result in obesity.

But if an entry in DSM-V is going to result in more stigma attached to being obesity, I think we should say no thanks.

What do you think?